Recently, Hwa Chong Institution (HCI) and Raffles Junior College (RJC) have been issueing non-academic "JC diplomas". What is a JC Diploma, you may ask. Simply put, it is a "degree" for outstanding students in non-academic areas to distinguish the best from the better.
I believe that such a JC Diploma system is rather feasible as it could likely be the differentiating factor between students. With more and more students scoring over 8As in their 'A' levels, universities all over the world find it hard to choose students to admit. This may likely be the answer for universities as this JC diploma separates the best from the best.
Furthermore, the university level of studies no longer aims for solely academic excellence, but also co-curricular talents. JC diplomas are able to identify these groups of more gifted students as it looks out for both academic excellence but also excellence beyond the text books.
However, though a viable bonus to students' portfolio, I believe that this JC diploma cannot completely replace the ‘A’ levels. If ‘A’ levels were to be removed and JC diplomas become the only education certificate JC students can obtain. As such, JC diplomas would have to be moderated to a certain level so that majority of the students will be able to obtain a college degree. However if more and more students gain a JC diploma, the dilemma of choosing students surfaces once again, thus bringing us back to square one.
On the other hand, if the requirements for obtaining a JC diploma were to be cranked up a notch, many of the JC students would only have a ‘O’ level certificate, effectively wasting two years of life in junior college.
Hence, I believe that the initialising of a JC diploma is not a bad idea. However, I personally feel that it would not be able to replace the ‘A’ levels, but instead act as a higher level of achievement and as I earlier mentioned, a differentiating factor between students, separating the cream of the crops from the others. Also, I believe that only a selected number of students can be awarded these JC diplomas thus increasing the uniqueness of such diplomas.